lon Musk caused chaos over his takeover bid for Twitter Inc, first claiming his bid was â€œtemporarily on holdâ€ and then maintaining he is â€œstill committedâ€ to the deal, sending the social media giant into a tailspin.
The billionaire initially sent an early tweet saying the $44 billion deal is pending until he receives more information about the proportion of fake accounts on the social media site, which sent Twitter stock tumbling as much as 25% in premarket trading. A few hours later he sent another tweet saying he is â€œstill committedâ€ to the deal. Twitterâ€™s shares recouped some of their losses but were down about 10%.
Musk said he was waiting for details on a recent filing from Twitter that fake accounts on the social media platform contributed less than 5% of its users. Twitter said in its latest quarterly results â€œthat the average of false or spam accounts during the first quarter of 2022 represented fewer than 5% of our monthly daily active users during the quarter.â€ However, Twitter said it applied â€œsignificant judgmentâ€ to its latest estimate, and the true number could be higher.
Fighting fake accounts has been a cornerstone of Muskâ€™s bid to reform Twitter. In a statement announcing his deal to buy the company last month, he revealed he wanted to defeat spam bots, authenticate all humans, and make its algorithms open source. Musk has also said heâ€™d like to make the platform a bastion of free speech, taking the guardrails off of content moderation.
Bots are currently allowed on Twitter, though under the companyâ€™s policy such accounts are supposed to indicate that theyâ€™re automated. The platform has even launched a label for â€œgoodâ€ bots, such as @tinycarebot, an account that tweets self-care reminders. Spam bots, however, are not permitted, and the company has policies meant to combat them.
Twitter deal temporarily on hold pending details supporting calculation that spam/fake accounts do indeed represent less than 5% of usershttps://t.co/Y2t0QMuuyn
â€” Elon Musk (@elonmusk) May 13, 2022
Doubts have grown in recent days that Musk would be able to pull off his acquisition of Twitter, and that the entrepreneur may consider dropping his bidding price for the micro-blogging site.
â€œThere will also be questions raised over whether fake accounts are the real reason behind this delaying tactic,â€ said Susannah Streeter, senior investment and markets analyst at Hargreaves Lansdown, â€œgiven that promoting free speech rather than focusing on wealth creation appeared to be his primary motivation for the takeover. The $44 billion price tag is huge, and it may be a strategy to row back on the amount he is prepared to pay to acquire the platform.â€
The proposed takeover includes a $1 billion breakup fee for each party, which Musk will have to pay if he ends the deal or fails to deliver the acquisition funding as promised. It is unclear whether an update by Twitter on the number of fake accountsâ€”if materially larger than 5%â€”would trigger a so-called material adverse effect clause, releasing Musk from the breakup fee.
The spread on the deal, which offers an indication of how much Wall Street believes the takeover will be completed, swelled further on Thursday to $9.11 from $8.11 in the previous session. That was the widest level since the billionaire launched his bid last month to purchase the Twitter for $54.20â€”and double where it was last week when he announced a roughly $7.1 billion financing commitment.
Muskâ€™s latest tweet landed just hours after news that Twitter was freezing hiring as part of pre-deal cost-cutting efforts. Two of Twitterâ€™s top leaders are also departing. Kayvon Beykpour, head of consumer product, and Bruce Falck, in charge of revenue product, were both asked to leave the company by Chief Executive Officer Parag Agrawal, the two executives said in separate public posts.
The changes reflect Twitterâ€™s current state of limbo while it awaits a new owner. Hindenburg Research LLC, an investment research firm that focuses on activist short-selling, said on Monday that it sees a â€œsignificant riskâ€ that Muskâ€™s proposed offer gets repriced lower.
The analysts cited the ongoing meltdown in technology shares, Twitterâ€™s own weak first-quarter results, including restating several years of user numbers, and the prospect that Musk will sell his 9% stake if the deal doesnâ€™t come together.
Aside from doubts over the extent of spam bots on Twitterâ€™s platform, the worldâ€™s richest person is still working to secure the money to actually complete the deal. Musk has been in talks with investors to raise enough equity and preferred financing to eliminate the need for any margin loan linked to his Tesla shares, according to people with knowledge of the matter.
He recently disclosed $7.1 billion in equity commitments from investors including Larry Ellison, Sequoia Capital, Qatar Holding and Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, with the latter rolling his Twitter stock into the deal.
â€œMusk has never had the full fundingâ€”we know that from his constant attempts to get financial supportâ€”but he also held all the cards,â€ said Neil Campling, head of TMT research at Mirabaud Equity Research. â€œThe Twitter board have been held hostage and only have themselves to blame for this mess. No other buyer will emerge â€“ if Musk decides he is still interested he can name his price and it wonâ€™t be higher.â€